Submitted by YoussefAssad on Sun, 29/10/2006 - 13:51.
GNU FDL
58% (22 votes)
CC Attribution-ShareAlike
16% (6 votes)
CC Attribution-NonCommercial
16% (6 votes)
Entirely free except to Sherif Nagy
11% (4 votes)
Total votes: 38

what's the basic differences

ramez.hanna's picture

although i've chosen GFDL, it was a not a very educated choice.
i read the CC licences breifly and looked at the GFDL page at wikipedia but i still can't determine the differences in the general terms. i mean what exactly is the license difference, i see both somehow permit redistribution.
for me what i care for is that my work under whatever license can be redistributed while maintaining the credits and the license (any body correct me please!).
i see that both licenses cover that but the GFDL goes more into technical details.
i'll read further but anyone who has a clear idea please contribute


the best things in life are free --- so as myself http://www.informatiq.org

the main reason to choose

Alaa's picture

the main reason to choose GFDL is to simplify copying content from places like wikipedia and the linux documentation project which use GFDL (CC and GFDL are not compatible licenses even if they seem to server similar purposes).

cheers,
Alaa


husband of the Grand Waragi Master

http://www.manalaa.net

ReVOTE

DarKnesS_WolF's picture

We have 43 Seniors " including the Admins and the mods " the vote is valid as we have more than 51% of senior users votes but the 1st option is not majority "2/3" of total votes

Minimum number of votes for a poll to be considered valid shall be 51% the number of senior users, moderators and administrators.
A two third majority in the poll will be considered conclusive. All votes are equal. In case polling period passes without reaching a two third majority the option with the least votes is removed from the poll and the poll is repeated, when the number of choices is down to two.

so i think we have to remove 2 options and revote. if i'm wrong please correct me


peace


Live Free Or Die Trying...
GPG Key ID:0x6FD809F4

To proceed

YoussefAssad's picture

Two options.

1. We can continue as the charter says and remove the last option and vote again, then face he possibility of voting again, and so on. Which is a pain in the culo. 2. We can say to ourselves "right, this is cumbersome and annoying. Let's decide to apply the results of this vote directly, and amend the charter when the right time comes"

I got for the second option. People, please chime in here. If within 5 days (21 November) there are no serious objections in this thread then I will ask the admins to apply option 2.

-- Panem et *burp* circenses

i do agree on the 2nd option

DarKnesS_WolF's picture


peace


Live Free Or Die Trying...
GPG Key ID:0x6FD809F4

huh?

phaeronix's picture

what happened to the pedantic charter defender ?

I know the issue is taking too long.. but I think we at least follow one of the rules of the charter. remove two choices and extend the poll time.

+me

khaledhosny's picture

+ me


My blog

which 2 options?

DarKnesS_WolF's picture

i don't know why ppl keep forgetten about this poll... ok which 2 options we will remove if we have 2 options " Share Alike , non-commercial" have the same votes?


peace


Live Free Or Die Trying...
GPG Key ID:0x6FD809F4

GFDL

DarKnesS_WolF's picture

OKay GFDL it is, Why ? beacuse the last option is like you don't like/want any of the license.. and we can't remove any other option of CC-SA or CC-NonComercial since both have the same shares.


peace


Live Free Or Die Trying...
GPG Key ID:0x6FD809F4

it does , remove Shiref

Conceptor's picture

it does , remove Shiref Nagy


Diaa Radwan

GFDL

DarKnesS_WolF's picture

this is the point removing the sherif option will not change anything about the next poll cuz it's already ppl who don't agree on any of the other options.


peace


Live Free Or Die Trying...
GPG Key ID:0x6FD809F4

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.